Mentoring High Achievers: A Guide for Small Business Owners

September 3, 2024
  • Foster a growth mindset in high achievers by sharing stories of failure as a learning tool and encouraging them to face hypothetical leadership challenges.
  • Develop emotional intelligence in leaders through regular feedback sessions, focusing on understanding their own and others' emotions.
  • Expand networks and influence by introducing high achievers to new contacts, encouraging participation in industry events, and employing the “24/7/30 model” for follow-ups to build lasting relationships.
  • Use these strategies to mentor top performers effectively, driving innovation and excellence in your business while fostering an environment that promotes growth, resilience, and leadership.



555 words ~ 1.5 min. read


As a small business owner or team leader, mentoring high achievers within your team can significantly enhance their potential and ultimately drive your business forward. A recent article in Harvard Business Review by leadership experts Ruth Gotian and Andy Lopata highlights the necessity of sophisticated mentoring for high achievers, offering three effective strategies to ensure top performers flourish. Read on to learn more about how to help your best and brightest reach their full potential.

 

Foster a Growth Mindset

Encouraging a growth mindset is crucial for high achievers. As Gotian and Lopata explain, highly successful individuals are less familiar with failure and may struggle with setbacks. Helping these leaders understand that there are lessons available ‘failing forward,’ can help them use failure to their advantage. 


Gotian and Lopata offer two crucial strategies for fostering a growth mindset among high achievers. First, they suggest sharing narratives of other elite performers who have encountered setbacks and their strategies for overcoming them. Secondly, they recommend engaging leaders in discussions about hypothetical challenging scenarios, such as adapting to abrupt changes in their field. These discussions are instrumental in helping high achievers perceive challenges and failures as opportunities for growth, aligning with their innate drive for improvement.


Develop Emotional Intelligence

Emotional intelligence (EQ) is a vital skill for leaders, particularly in small business environments where interpersonal relationships are foundational. As a mentor, Gotian and Lopata recommend helping high achievers gain insights into their emotions as well as those of others. Regular feedback sessions can help in this area by providing structured opportunities for self-reflection. Discuss specific instances where their emotional responses influenced outcomes, in order to facilitate a deeper understanding of their leadership style and interactions with colleagues. This focus can be particularly beneficial for those less inclined towards techniques like journaling or meditation.


Expand Networks and Influence

A strong network is crucial for high achievers aiming to expand their success.Often, these individuals have established connections but may overlook key relationships that could enhance their success. As a mentor, you can play a pivotal role in identifying these blind spots. Facilitate introductions to new contacts, including thought leaders and innovators from various sectors. Encouraging attendance at industry conferences or participation in cross-industry collaborations can yield fresh insights and broaden horizons.


A practical approach to maintaining these new connections is utilizing what Gotian and Lopata call the “24/7/30 model” for follow-ups. This approach provides a straightforward template for individuals to reach out 24 hours after meeting, again after 7 days, and once more after 30 days. This simple strategy helps turn fleeting encounters into lasting relationships, which can be instrumental in developing long-term relationships and networks that can help top performers grow.

 

The Takeaway

Mentoring top performers needs a smart approach. The HBR article points out that using techniques to develop a growth mindset, improve emotional intelligence, and widen networks can help these individuals—and your business—achieve more. The main aim of mentorship is to motivate and back up your team leaders, helping them keep up their success and grow into leaders who can drive innovation and excellence.


By putting these methods into practice, small business owners can create a setting that encourages growth, toughness, and leadership, making a big difference in their company's long-term success and survival.



---

The Leavenworth-Lansing Area Chamber of Commerce is a private non-profit organization that aims to support the growth and development of local businesses and our regional economy. We strive to create content that not only educates but also fosters a sense of connection and collaboration among our readers. Join us as we explore topics such as economic development, networking opportunities, upcoming events, and success stories from our vibrant community. Our resources provide insights, advice, and news that are relevant to business owners, entrepreneurs, and community members alike. The Chamber has been granted license to publish this content provided by Chamber Today, a service of ChamberThink Strategies LLC. 


March 16, 2026
If you’re a small business owner, you probably didn’t wake up one morning and declare, “Today, I’m going to be an executive.” That would’ve required time for reflection and who has that when you’re running a business? Most entrepreneurs don’t get that luxury. One day you’re making the thing, selling the thing, fixing the thing, or delivering the service. The next day you’re managing schedules, answering payroll questions, resolving customer issues, and trying to figure out why the printer refuses to cooperate with the accounting software. Somewhere along the way, you stopped being the person who does the work and became the person responsible for making sure the work happens. This is the moment many small business owners quietly become what could best be described as the Accidental Executive. You may never call yourself a CEO. In fact, most owners of small and mid-sized businesses would laugh at the idea. But if you’re overseeing staff, coordinating multiple functions of the business, making financial decisions, and setting direction for the future, you’re already operating at an executive level whether the title exists or not. The Maker Phase Nearly every small business begins in what could be called the “maker phase.” A person has a skill, a craft, or a service people want. A baker opens a shop. A contractor starts taking on projects. A designer begins freelancing. A consultant lands their first few clients. In this phase, success comes from being good at the work itself. You’re the engine of the business. If you stop producing, the business stops moving. You’re also trading time for money and since there is a limited number of hours in the day, you can only grow so much under that structure. For many entrepreneurs, this stage feels natural. The work is familiar. The results are visible. Effort goes in and something tangible comes out. But there is another dynamic at play in those early days. Most of your first customers aren’t buying because of a sophisticated marketing plan. They buy because they know you. They trust you. Someone recommended you. Maybe they met you through a community group, a chamber event, or a mutual connection. You shake their hand. You show up personally. You solve their problem. Those early relationships become the foundation of the business. They lead to repeat customers and referrals. In the beginning, your reputation travels faster than your marketing. Then something interesting happens. Customers start showing up more often. The business grows. And suddenly you can’t do everything anymore. The First Hires Change Everything Hiring the first employee is a proud moment. It signals growth and momentum. But it also quietly shifts your role. Now someone needs direction, training, and feedback. There are schedules to approve, paychecks to process, and questions to answer. Multiply that by three, five, or ten people and the nature of the job changes entirely. The owner is no longer producing the work. You’re coordinating it. Many business owners still think of themselves as the primary worker in the business even after this shift happens. But if your day is filled with conversations, decisions, troubleshooting, and planning instead of the original craft, the role has already changed. You are no longer the maker. You’re the person running the operation. And you need to make that transition if you want to grow. When Clients Miss Seeing You There is another subtle shift that often surprises growing businesses. In the early days, customers bought directly from you. They saw you on every visit. You answered the phone and handled the details. You were the face of the service. As the business grows, that changes. Employees begin doing the work. New team members show up at client sites or in the store. You become the person overseeing the business rather than the person performing the service. Often longtime clients feel that change. They might say something like, “We never see you anymore,” or “We miss working with you.” It’s not necessarily a complaint. It’s simply a reflection of change and people don’t always like change. The client trusted you personally, and now the relationship is shifting from a one-to-one connection to a relationship with the company. For many owners, this moment feels uncomfortable. It can create a sense that something important is being lost. But it doesn’t have to be. The key is making sure the client’s trust transfers from you to the organization. One simple way to do this is to intentionally introduce your team as an extension of you. Let clients know who will be working with them and why you trust that person. Share their strengths. Position them as capable professionals, not just employees filling in for the owner. At the same time, maintain a visible presence in the relationship. A quick check-in call, a brief email after a project, or an occasional visit can reassure clients that you are still engaged and accountable. You may not be doing the work personally anymore, but they are still guaranteeing the quality of the work. The Uncomfortable Truth This stage can feel frustrating because the skills that made you successful early on are no longer the skills the business needs most. Being a great mechanic does not automatically prepare you to manage technicians, negotiate vendor relationships, and analyze pricing strategies. Being a talented photographer does not immediately translate into managing a studio schedule, marketing campaigns, and customer service policies. Running a growing business requires a completely different set of abilities. Leadership. Communication. Delegation. Decision-making. Strategic thinking. These are executive-level skills, even if the business only has a handful of employees. The uncomfortable truth is that many owners are never formally taught how to make this transition. Most are figuring it out in real time while trying to keep the business moving forward. Why This Transition Matters When business owners don’t recognize their role has changed, they often continue trying to operate as the primary worker while also managing the entire organization. That combination rarely works for long. Owners become overwhelmed. Employees feel micromanaged and confused about their role. Recognizing the shift from maker to accidental executive allows owners to approach their role differently. Instead of trying to do everything personally, the focus moves to building systems, developing people, and creating structure that allows the business to operate effectively. Your work becomes less about personal output and more about guiding the entire operation. Over the course of your business’ lifetime, your role will likely transition several times from doer to manager to executive leadership where operational duties fall to others. The Chamber Can Help This is exactly where business networks and community support become valuable. Many small business owners are navigating these leadership shifts. Connecting with other business owners provides perspective that cannot be found inside the walls of your company. Conversations at networking events, leadership programs, workshops, and peer groups often reveal something powerful. Nearly everyone is figuring it out as they go. Hearing how other owners approached hiring, delegation, growth, and leadership challenges can shorten the learning curve dramatically. The chamber environment creates space for those conversations to happen (and sometimes the leadership training too). The Title Isn’t the Point Whether someone calls themselves an owner, founder, partner, or president does not really matter. What matters is recognizing the moment when the business begins requiring executive-level thinking. Once you shift from doer to manager (or exec), the path forward changes. The goal is no longer simply doing the work well. The goal becomes building a business where many people can do the work well and thrive. That’s the real difference between doing a job and leading an organization. Read More: Business.com First Time Hiring Guide Is Your Business Owner-Dependent? How to Build a Culture People Want to Be a Part of Succession Planning Workbook - a resource for planning. Created to help you identify key people/positions that should have redundancies in place and help get a guideline for training and replacements. Free for Chamber Members. ----------- Christina Metcalf is a writer and women’s speaker who believes in the power of story. She works with small businesses, chambers of commerce, and business professionals who want to make an impression and grow a loyal customer/member base. She is the author of The Glinda Principle , rediscovering the magic within. _______________________________________ Facebook: @tellyourstorygetemtalking Instagram: @christinametcalfauthor LinkedIn: @christinametcalf5
March 9, 2026
For a small business owner, the most critical piece of equipment isn't your laptop, your CRM, or your delivery van—it’s your brain. When you are the visionary, the strategist, and the customer service department, your cognitive clarity determines your bottom line. However, "founder’s fatigue" often leads to the dreaded brain fog: that sluggish, scattered feeling where making a simple decision feels like wading through molasses. Here’s how to optimize your neural hardware for peak performance and clear the fog of overload. You do it for your equipment. You deserve (at least) the same level of care. 1. Master the "Context Switching" Fee Every time you jump from an invoice to a marketing tweet to a customer complaint, your brain pays a switching fee. Research suggests this can lower productivity by up to 40%. The Fix: Time-Batching. Group similar tasks together. Dedicate Tuesday mornings solely to social media content for the month and Thursday afternoons to invoicing. This allows your brain to stay in one "mode" and reduces the cognitive load of pivoting between these very different tasks. 2. Fuel the Biological Machine Your brain represents only 2% of your body weight but consumes about 20% of its energy. If you fuel it with erratic caffeine spikes and skipped lunches, it will underperform. The Fix: Prioritize neuro-protective fats (like Omega-3s) and complex carbohydrates that provide a steady stream of glucose. Most importantly, hydration is non-negotiable; even 2% dehydration can significantly impair tasks that require attention and memory. 3. Implement an "External Brain" Brain fog is often the result of Open Loop Syndrome—the mental exhaustion caused by trying to remember ten different unfinished tasks. Just like on your computer when you have too many tabs open, performance decreases. The Fix: Use a Capture System. Whether you use a digital app or a physical notebook, get every "to-do" or concern out of your head the moment it appears. When your brain knows the information is recorded safely elsewhere, it can stop using energy on that thought, freeing up bandwidth for deep work. 4. Optimize Your Sleep Architecture Sleep isn't just downtime. It’s when your brain’s glymphatic system flushes out metabolic waste (essentially "washing" your brain). For a business owner, a missed hour of sleep is a direct hit to your emotional intelligence and decision-making speed, not to mention it often impacts your personality and desire to do the difficult work. The Fix: View sleep as a non-negotiable business appointment. Aim for a consistent "wind-down" period 30 minutes before bed where screens are banned. Quick Tips for Immediate Fog-Clearing When you hit a wall in the middle of the workday, try these easy pattern interrupters: · The 10-Minute Walk - Increases blood flow to the hippocampus and resets focus. · Box Breathing - Inhale for 4, hold for 4, exhale for 4, hold for 4. Calms the nervous system. · Single-Tasking - Close every tab except the one you’re currently working on. · Cold Exposure - A splash of cold water on the face triggers the diving reflex, slowing heart rate and increasing alertness. You don’t need to work more hours. Instead, make the hours you work more effective. By treating your brain with the same respect you give your business finances or equipment, you'll find that the fog lifts, leaving room for the clarity and innovation that started your business in the first place. Read More: 4 Simple Management Tasks to Make More of Your Limited Time Breaking the Burnout Cycle for Small Business Success Why Having a Hobby is Great for Business -------- Christina Metcalf is a writer and women’s speaker who believes in the power of story. She works with small businesses, chambers of commerce, and business professionals who want to make an impression and grow a loyal customer/member base. She’s the author of The Glinda Principle , rediscovering the magic within and is currently writing a book for burnt-out overachievers entitled, When Great Isn’t Good. _______________________________________ Facebook: @tellyourstorygetemtalking Instagram: @christinametcalfauthor LinkedIn: @christinametcalf5
March 2, 2026
A Simple Guide for New and Growing Businesses